Case Studies••8 min read

Federal Court Dismisses EB-5 Delay Lawsuit Against DHS — Nov 19, 2026, 3:00 AM

A federal court rejected a 32-month EB-5 processing-delay challenge, reinforcing the difficulty of proving unreasonable agency delay. Investors should document delays and evaluate tailored legal strategies.

A federal court in Washington, D.C., has dismissed a lawsuit challenging the Department of Homeland Security’s delay in deciding an EB-5 immigrant investor petition. In Lu v. Mullin, Civil Action No. 2026-1157, the court concluded that an approximately 32-month delay in adjudicating a Form I-526E petition was not unreasonable under the circumstances reported in the decision.[1]

The ruling is significant for EB-5 investors who are waiting years for agency action and are considering a federal lawsuit to compel a decision. Although federal courts can order an agency to act when delays become legally unreasonable, Lu demonstrates that a long wait alone may not guarantee success.

What the Court Decided

The plaintiff, Chen-Chia Lu, filed a Form I-526E petition seeking classification through the EB-5 immigrant investor program. After approximately three years without a final decision, Lu sued DHS and federal officials, alleging that the delay violated the law and was unreasonable.[1]

The defendants asked the court to dismiss the claims. Lu filed a cross-motion for summary judgment, seeking relief based on the alleged failure to adjudicate the petition promptly. Judge Reggie B. Walton granted the government’s motion to dismiss and denied Lu’s cross-motion.[1]

The court’s conclusion was not that agencies may delay immigration cases indefinitely. Instead, the decision reflects the fact-specific analysis courts apply when determining whether administrative delay is unlawful. The court found that the reported 32-month delay did not meet that standard in this case.[1]

Why the Decision Matters to EB-5 Investors

EB-5 litigation frequently involves a request for a writ of mandamus or relief under the Administrative Procedure Act. These lawsuits generally ask a federal court to require U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, DHS, or another agency to take action on a long-pending application.

A mandamus case ordinarily seeks a decision—not approval of the immigration benefit. A court may order the agency to adjudicate a petition, but it generally will not direct the agency to approve a petition that has not yet been fully evaluated.

The Lu decision highlights several practical realities:

  • A lengthy processing period does not automatically establish unlawful delay.
  • Courts may consider the agency’s overall processing framework and competing demands on government resources.
  • The individual facts surrounding the petition can affect whether litigation is appropriate.
  • A lawsuit can result in an adjudication, but it cannot eliminate substantive eligibility requirements.
  • Dismissal of one delay case does not create a universal rule for every EB-5 investor or every USCIS delay.

Understanding the EB-5 Delay Problem

The EB-5 program allows qualifying investors and eligible family members to pursue permanent residence through a qualifying investment and job-creation requirements. The process can involve multiple stages, including the initial investor petition, adjustment of status or consular processing, and—in some cases—removal of conditions on residence.

Processing delays may create serious consequences. An investor may face uncertainty about business planning, family relocation, employment authorization, travel, or the expiration of a temporary immigration status. Delays can also affect children approaching age-out concerns, although the legal effect depends on the relevant facts and statutory protections.

Because of these consequences, some investors consider federal litigation. The strength of a potential case depends on more than the age of the petition. Counsel may need to examine the petition’s category, filing date, project information, requests for evidence, security checks, visa availability, prior notices, and any communications from USCIS.

How Courts Evaluate Unreasonable Delay

Federal courts commonly analyze delay claims under a fact-specific framework often associated with the factors identified in Telecommunications Research & Action Center v. FCC, 750 F.2d 70 (D.C. Cir. 1984). Courts may consider the length of the delay, the reason for the delay, the interests prejudiced by the delay, and the effect of granting relief on agency priorities and other applicants.

Courts may also consider whether Congress provided a timetable, whether the agency has taken steps to process the case, and whether the requested relief would improperly reorder the agency’s docket. The analysis varies by jurisdiction and by the procedural posture of the case.

The key question is typically whether the delay is unreasonable in context—not simply whether it is frustrating or longer than the applicant expected. The government may argue that the agency is handling cases according to a rational system and that an order in one case would unfairly place that applicant ahead of others.

Delay is different from an adverse decision

An investor whose petition has been denied faces a different legal issue from an investor whose petition remains pending. A delay lawsuit generally concerns the agency’s failure to act. It does not replace the administrative appeal or motion procedures that may apply after a denial.

Before filing suit, an applicant should determine whether the case is truly pending, whether USCIS has issued a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny, and whether the agency has identified a missing filing or procedural problem.

Actionable Guidance for Investors Facing Long Delays

1. Confirm the case status and record

Collect the receipt notice, filing package, biometric notices, requests for evidence, responses, interview notices, online status history, and correspondence with USCIS or the investor’s regional center. A complete timeline helps counsel determine whether the delay is ordinary, unusual, or affected by a pending agency request.

2. Check visa availability and eligibility

Delay litigation should be evaluated alongside visa availability and the investor’s substantive eligibility. A court order compelling adjudication may create an immediate decision, so the applicant should understand whether the petition is approvable and whether the next immigration step is currently available.

3. Consider age-out and family consequences

Families should identify children who may approach the age of 21 and review whether the Child Status Protection Act or another protection could apply. The applicable calculation can be technical, and relying solely on an online case estimate may create avoidable risk.

4. Preserve lawful status and work authorization

Investors in the United States should review the expiration dates of their nonimmigrant status, employment authorization documents, and travel documents. A pending EB-5 petition does not automatically provide lawful status or employment authorization. Separate applications or status strategies may be necessary.

5. Use agency inquiries strategically

Before filing a lawsuit, counsel may consider a service request, congressional inquiry, contact with the USCIS ombudsman, or other appropriate administrative follow-up. These steps do not guarantee action, but they can clarify the case’s location and identify unresolved issues.

6. Obtain a case-specific litigation assessment

A delay lawsuit should be based on the individual record, not solely on the number of months that have passed. An immigration attorney can assess jurisdiction, venue, defendants, litigation costs, potential government responses, and the risks of receiving a denial rather than an approval.

What the Ruling Does Not Mean

The decision does not mean that every EB-5 delay is lawful. It also does not prevent other investors from pursuing mandamus or Administrative Procedure Act claims when their circumstances support relief. Federal courts may reach different conclusions based on the agency’s explanation, the case’s procedural history, the length of the delay, or the harm to the applicant.

The ruling likewise does not change the statutory requirements of the EB-5 program. Investors must still satisfy applicable investment, lawful-source-of-funds, and job-creation requirements. A court order requiring USCIS to act cannot waive those requirements.

Potential Next Steps After Dismissal

The reported decision indicates that Lu may consider an appeal, although the available report did not identify a filed appeal.[1] The timing and viability of an appeal would depend on the final judgment, appellate deadlines, the legal issues preserved, and the applicable federal appellate rules.

Other EB-5 investors should not assume that the dismissal automatically resolves or defeats their own potential claims. A federal court’s analysis may be persuasive, but the outcome of a delay case remains dependent on the facts, jurisdiction, and claims presented.

How Imigrar Can Help

Investors experiencing prolonged EB-5 processing delays should obtain a comprehensive review before taking action. Imigrar can help evaluate the petition history, identify family and status concerns, assess administrative options, and determine whether federal litigation may be appropriate.

Because a mandamus action seeks agency action rather than guaranteed approval, the decision to sue should follow a careful review of the underlying petition and the investor’s broader immigration plan. Families should also avoid allowing a pending petition to obscure separate deadlines involving status, employment authorization, travel, or children’s eligibility.

Legal information disclaimer: This article provides general information about a reported federal court decision and is not legal advice. Immigration outcomes depend on individual facts, current law, agency policy, and court decisions. Consult a qualified immigration attorney before filing a lawsuit or changing an immigration strategy.

Sources

  • Lu v. Mullin, Civil Action No. 2026-1157, U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, as reported November 18, 2026.[1]
  • Telecommunications Research & Action Center v. FCC, 750 F.2d 70 (D.C. Cir. 1984).

Related Topics

EB-5 visaimmigration litigationUSCIS delaysmandamus lawsuitsDHSimmigration lawOrlando immigration attorney

Need Legal Assistance?

Our experienced immigration attorneys are here to help with your case. Contact Imigrar today for a free consultation and let us guide you through the legal process with confidence.

📍 Orlando, Florida • Serving clients nationwide
📧 info@imigrar.com

Share this article

More Articles